Assisting Individuals With Legal Matters Since 1955
What to Say to Insurers After a NJ Car Accident
Contact Us Now
When the adjuster calls, every word can affect your claim. This guide shows what to say, what to avoid, and how New Jersey rules shape the conversation.
If you need tailored help, talk with a New Jersey car accident lawyer at Aiello Harris
What you’ll learn in this guide
- Short scripts for first-party and third-party calls
- NJ-specific timelines and rights
- A clear plan for statements, documents, and follow-up
New Jersey Rules That Shape the Conversation
- No-fault/PIP starts with your policy. Medical treatment usually flows through Personal Injury Protection (PIP) on your own policy, regardless of fault. We’ll show what your own insurer can request and why.
- Third-party property damage timelines. The other driver’s insurance should contact you within 10 working days after notice, and if they choose to inspect your car, they must do so within seven working days. Third-party property claims should be settled within 45 days; if not, the carrier must give written reasons for the delay. Use these benchmarks to keep the process moving.
Unfair claims standards. NJ rules require fair explanations and timely communications during claims handling. These standards help you request written responses and ask for rule-based reasons when something stalls.
First-Party vs. Third-Party — Know Your Duties
First-party (your insurer)
- Your policy generally requires cooperation. Under N.J.S.A. 39:6A-13, your PIP carrier can request targeted information and may ask for an exam. Keep requests in writing and respond through your lawyer when possible.
Third-party (the other driver’s insurer)
- You do not owe the adverse insurance carrier a recorded statement. You can decline and refer the adjuster to your attorney. Keep the exchange polite and brief.
Simple declination script
“I’m not comfortable giving a recorded statement. Please send any questions in writing to me and my attorney.”
Exactly What to Say (Short Scripts You Can Use)
When your own insurer calls
- “My name is [name], policy [number]. The crash was on [date/time] at [location]. I will send the police report number and photos.”
- “I’m being evaluated and following my doctor’s guidance.”
- “Please email any forms or requests so I can respond in writing.”
When the other driver’s insurer calls
- “I can confirm my name and contact information. I’m not providing a recorded statement. Please get in touch with my attorney.”
- “For documents, email a list of what you need. I’ll review with my attorney.”
If they push for details
- “I prefer to keep communications in writing.”
What Not to Say (Common Traps)
- Don’t guess about speed, distance, or fault.
- Don’t say “I’m fine.” Some injuries show up later.
- Don’t speculate about what others saw or thought.
- Don’t sign broad medical authorizations for the other driver’s insurer. Medical releases should be relevant and limited; route requests through counsel. Your own PIP carrier’s requests are governed by statute and rule.
PIP Process, Forms, and Timelines (Why Adjusters Ask for Certain Things)
New Jersey uses decision-point review and care paths for specific injuries and diagnostic tests. Your insurer or vendor may require pre-certification and outline how to submit requests and how quickly they will respond. If care is denied or reduced, there is an internal appeal process. Knowing these mechanics makes the paperwork less frustrating. Keep copies of every form, EOB, and decision letter.
- Ask for time frames in writing when pre-cert is pending.
- If payment is delayed, request a written explanation that references the rule.
NJ Deadlines When the Other Insurer Handles Property Damage
- Contact within 10 working days after notice.
- Inspection within 7 working days if they choose to.
- Aim to settle in 45 days or receive a written reason for the delay.
Tip: When timelines slip, email the adjuster to confirm the reason and next target date.
If the Crash Happened While You Were Working
Work-related crashes involve coordination with workers’ compensation for medical benefits, which can change the benefits order before PIP. Tell your lawyer and insurance carrier immediately so your statements and authorizations stay consistent with the benefit that applies first.
Insurer Medical Exams (IME): Recording and Observers
New Jersey’s high court confirmed that trial courts decide case-by-case whether IME conditions are allowed, including whether an observer or recording is permitted. There are no automatic bans or guarantees. If an exam is requested during litigation, your attorney can address conditions through motion practice under the court rules.
Timelines, Benefits, and Thresholds That Affect Settlement
New Jersey’s verbal threshold limits pain-and-suffering claims unless injuries meet specific categories (death, dismemberment, loss of fetus, significant scarring/disfigurement, displaced fracture, or permanent injury). Your tort option and medical records will shape negotiations.
FAQs
Can I record the insurer’s medical exam?
It depends on the court’s order in your case; speak with your attorney about requesting conditions.
Do I have to give a recorded statement?
Your insurer: Your policy may require cooperation; your PIP carrier can seek targeted information by statute. Do this with your lawyer.
Other driver’s insurer: No duty. You can decline and refer them to your attorney.
How fast should the other insurer respond to property damage?
Contact within 10 working days; inspect within seven working days if they inspect; aim to settle in 45 days, or they should provide a written reason for the delay.
Who can help if the claim stalls?
Start with your carrier’s internal appeal or supervisor. For many issues, you can contact the NJDOBI Consumer Assistance/Ombudsman. Note: PIP disputes often go to arbitration, not the Ombudsman.
Can I choose my doctors under PIP?
Network rules, decision-point review, and pre-cert may apply. Document the process in writing and retain all approvals/denials.
Contact us today
Get a clear plan before you speak with your insurance carrier’s adjuster again. Aiello Harris Abate Law Group PC can review your policy, organize documents, and handle insurer communications.
Call us today at (908) 561-5577 or contact us. Your initial consultation will take place over the phone, and you can schedule an appointment at one of our office locations across New Jersey.
Contact our What to Say to Insurers After a NJ Car Accident
Meet Our Team
The Aiello Harris Abate Law Group is made of a group of professionals that are here to help you through all challenges.
Get to Know UsLegal Practice Areas
Our law firm does not stop at What to Say to Insurers After a NJ Car Accident — take a look at how we can help you overcome your legal obstacles.
View all Practice Areas