Assisting Individuals With Legal Matters Since 1955
What to Do After a Car Accident in NJ
Contact Us Now
If you were just hit, you need a clear plan that protects your health, your claim, and your rights under New Jersey law. This guide explains each step, why it matters, and where the rules come from. It also shows you how PIP works, how the verbal threshold can limit pain-and-suffering claims, and what insurance changes in 2023–2026 mean for your case.
Need answers now? Call Aiello Harris Abate Law Group PC at (908) 561-5577 for an initial phone consultation.
Quick-Glance Checklist
- Move to a safe spot, turn on hazards, call 911.
- Exchange information and give reasonable aid as required by law.
- Ask for police. A crash with injury/death or property damage of $500+ triggers reporting duties.
- Photograph vehicles, positions, damage, skid marks, traffic controls, weather, and injuries.
- Get witness names and contact info. Look for nearby cameras.
- Keep statements factual. Do not speculate or accept blame at the scene.
- Seek medical care the same day if you feel any pain, dizziness, numbness, or confusion.
- Open a PIP claim with your insurer and give providers the claim number.
- Call the firm before any recorded statement with the other driver’s insurer.
The Legal Framework You’re Operating Under
Duties at the Scene
New Jersey requires drivers involved in a crash to stop, remain, exchange information, and render reasonable assistance. Leaving the scene brings serious penalties.
Written Crash Reports
- Drivers: file a written report within 10 days when there is injury/death or property damage of $500+, unless a police officer files a report.
- Police: for reportable crashes, officers submit the NJTR-1 to the MVC within 5 days. This is why your report usually isn’t available right away.
PIP (Personal Injury Protection)
PIP pays medical bills regardless of fault. Disagreements over payment routes into PIP dispute resolution. The state also enforces prompt-pay timing for certain benefits.
Tort Options and the Verbal Threshold
New Jersey lets policyholders choose a limitation on lawsuit (verbal threshold) or no limitation on lawsuits (often called Zero Threshold). Pain-and-suffering claims under the limitation must fit specific injury categories: death, dismemberment, significant scarring/disfigurement, displaced fractures, loss of a fetus, or permanent injury proven within a reasonable degree of medical probability.
Comparative Negligence
A jury can assign fault percentages to everyone involved. Your recovery drops by your share of fault and is barred if your fault is greater than 50%.
Step-by-Step After the Crash
At the Scene
- Call 911. Ask for police and EMTs.
- Exchange license, registration, and insurance. If a driver refuses, photograph the plate and vehicle.
- Capture the evidence you cannot recreate later: the resting positions, debris, skid marks, fresh fluid trails, and any malfunctioning traffic control.
- Ask nearby businesses and homes if their cameras face the street. Note camera locations for follow-up.
- Keep conversation short and factual. Do not apologize or guess what happened.
Within 24–48 Hours
- Get a medical exam even if you feel “okay.” Many injuries surface later. Keep discharge papers and prescriptions.
- Open your PIP claim and give that number to every provider.
- Ask the police department how to obtain your NJTR-1 report once filed.
In the First Week
- Create a claim folder: photos, bills, receipts, medication lists, time missed from work, repair estimates, rental receipts.
- Schedule at least one follow-up medical visit if symptoms continue. Missed appointments can undermine credibility.
- Speak with your own insurer as required by your policy. Decline a recorded statement to the other insurer until you speak with counsel.
Ongoing
- Keep a short journal of pain, sleep issues, mobility limits, and missed life events.
- Save every bill and EOB. Photograph bruising or swelling as it changes.
- Follow the treatment plan. Consistent care reduces disputes about “gaps” and “non-compliance.”
Insurance Mechanics in Plain English
PIP Pays First
PIP is your primary for medicals. Providers submit bills under your claim; disputes often go to PIP arbitration. Prompt-pay rules may apply to the carrier’s timing.
Property Damage Paths
Collision coverage can repair your car faster, with later reimbursement through subrogation against the at-fault carrier. If you do not carry collision, the other carrier may still inspect and pay when liability is clear, but timing varies.
UM and UIM
When the at-fault driver has no insurance (UM) or too little (UIM), your own policy can fill the gap. New Jersey raised mandatory limits in two steps:
2023–2026: NJ Minimum Insurance Limits Increased
- Policies issued/renewed on/after Jan 1, 2023 moved to $25k/$50k.
- Policies issued/renewed on/after Jan 1, 2026 move to $35k/$70k.
UM/UIM provisions track these limits. This can raise available coverage on newer policies.
Practice pointer: UIM step-down language and declarations pages can conflict. In Motil v. Wausau (2024), the Appellate Division sided with the insured based on reasonable expectations created by the dec page. A policy review early in the case can be decisive.
Policy deadlines: Some policies shorten the time to bring a UIM claim. A 2025 decision discusses a four-year limitations period applied through policy language. Treat policy time limits as real deadlines.
Liability, Defenses, and How Insurers Push Back
Comparative fault: speeding, distraction, tailgating, unsafe lane changes. Your percentage reduces recovery and can end it at >50%.
Verbal threshold defense: carriers argue injuries do not meet 39:6A-8(a) categories or lack objective proof of permanency. Thorough records and specialist support answer this.
Causation attacks: pre-existing conditions, gaps in treatment, delay in first care.
Low-impact arguments: property-damage photos do not tell the whole story; medical documentation does.
Evidence That Moves the Needle
Official records: NJTR-1 crash report; sometimes CAD/911 audio; body-cam or dash-cam when available.
Scene evidence: photographs, debris fields, yaw marks, lighting cycles, weather data.
Digital sources: vehicle event data recorders, telematics, cell-phone use data, nearby surveillance footage.
Medical proof: diagnosis notes, imaging, objective testing, specialist narratives describing function limits and prognosis.
Economic proof: pay stubs, employer letters, tax returns, caregiver or household-service logs.
Injuries and the Verbal Threshold
If your policy carries the limitation on lawsuit, a pain-and-suffering claim must fit one of these categories: death, dismemberment, significant scarring or disfigurement, displaced fractures, loss of a fetus, or permanent injury within a reasonable degree of medical probability. Objective findings matter, and treating-physician narratives help the court understand lasting impact.
A steady medical record closes the door on arguments about gaps or lack of permanence.
Deadlines and Milestones
Injury claims: generally, 2 years from the date of the crash for bodily injury claims against the at-fault driver, subject to exceptions.
Driver written report: 10 days for injury/death or $500+ property damage unless an officer files.
Police NJTR-1: officers submit within 5 days for reportable crashes.
Insurance notice: your policy may require prompt notice and cooperation.
UM/UIM timing: watch policy-specific limitation periods; some shorten the window.
Special Scenarios
Hit-and-run: file police report right away and open a UM claim.
Out-of-state drivers: coverage can conform to New Jersey law in many cases when authorized carriers are involved; threshold questions can shift with policy terms.
Rideshare (Uber/Lyft): layered coverage may apply depending on whether the app was on and the trip status.
Commercial trucks (intrastate): liability minimums for New Jersey-based intrastate carriers increased under DOBI Bulletin 24-07; larger BI limits may be available.
Municipal vehicles: notice requirements and short timelines can apply.
Settlement, Litigation, and Damages
Claim flow: start with PIP for medicals → pursue bodily injury liability claim → evaluate UM/UIM if the at-fault limits are low.
Damages: medical expenses, wage loss, household services, and, where allowed pain and suffering.
Where cases get decided: PIP billing fights often go to dispute resolution; injury cases proceed in Superior Court when settlement stalls.
FAQs
Do I have to call police for a minor crash?
If anyone is hurt, or damage appears to meet or exceed $500, involve police and follow reporting rules.
Who pays my ER bill?
PIP pays first, then subrogation sorts out fault later.
Can I recover if I’m partly at fault?
Yes, unless your share is greater than 50%. Your recovery drops by your percentage.
What if the other driver fled?
File a police report and open a UM claim through your own policy.
What are NJ’s current minimum auto limits?
Policies issued/renewed 2023–2025: $25k/$50k.
Policies issued/renewed on/after Jan 1, 2026: $35k/$70k.
Do police have a deadline to file the crash report?
Yes. For reportable crashes, the officer files the NJTR-1 within 5 days.
Why does my lawyer care about a “permanency certification”?
With the limitation on lawsuit, you need objective proof that fits 39:6A-8(a).
Can my UIM deadline be shorter than six years?
Some policies shorten it. A 2025 Appellate Division decision addressed a four-year period in policy language.
Contact us today
Call us today at (908) 561-5577 or contact us. Your initial consultation will take place over the phone, and you can schedule an appointment at one of our office locations across New Jersey.
Contact our What to Do After a Car Accident in NJ
Meet Our Team
The Aiello Harris Abate Law Group is made of a group of professionals that are here to help you through all challenges.
Get to Know UsLegal Practice Areas
Our law firm does not stop at What to Do After a Car Accident in NJ — take a look at how we can help you overcome your legal obstacles.
View all Practice Areas